VI. Earth Life Emergence: Development of Body, Brain, Selves and Societies
A. A Survey of Common Principles
Roehner, Bertrand. Driving Forces in Physical, Biological and Socio-Economic Phenomena. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. A University of Paris physicist applies network principles to group bonding and pathologies. Somewhat narrow and technical, it is noted because it opens with the observation that both the widely separated early elemental universe and later Neolithic societies can be seen to form by the same aggregative dynamics.
Root-Bernstein, Robert. A Modular Hierarchy-based Theory of the Chemical Origins of Life Based on Molecular Complementarity. Accounts of Chemical Research. 45/12, 2012. The Michigan State University polymath physiologist stays on message with another exposition about nature’s constant propensity to create and evolve by way of reciprocal mating pairs. With a philosophy PhD with Thomas Kuhn and a postdoc with Jonas Salk, he has made contributions to AIDS and autoimmunity research, along with blending science and the arts. See also his The Ribosome as a Missing Link in the Evolution of Life in the Journal of Theoretical Biology (Online December 2014), and Molecular Complementarity Between Simple, Universal Molecules and Ions with Vic Norris, et al in Biology Direct (9/28, 2014).
Molecular complementarity plays critical roles in the evolution of chemical systems and resolves a significant number of outstanding problems in the emergence of complex systems. All physical and mathematical models of organization within complex systems rely upon nonrandom linkage between components. Molecular complementarity provides a naturally occurring nonrandom linker. More importantly, the formation of hierarchically organized stable modules vastly improves the probability of achieving self-organization, and molecular complementarity provides a mechanism by which hierarchically organized stable modules can form. In sum, I propose that molecular complementarity is ubiquitous in living systems because it provides the physicochemical basis for modular, hierarchical ordering and replication necessary for the evolution of the chemical systems upon which life is based. I conjecture that complementarity more generally is an essential agent that mediates evolution at every level of organization. (Abstract)
Rosas, Fernando. Quantifying High-Order Interdependencies via Multivariate Extensions of the Mutual Information. Physical Review E. 100/032305, 2019. Imperial College London mathematicians including Henrik Jensen report a technical exercise about ways to perceive and express nature’s emergent, animate scales. A prime feature seems to be an intrinsic synergy between all manner of entities and their informed, cooperative behaviors. A similar motif in musical compositions is offered as an example, indeed a true music and harmony of the spheres, and oour creaturely lives does play. See also Tangled Worldview Model of Opinion Dynamics by this group at arXiv:1901.06372.
This article introduces a model-agnostic approach to study statistical synergy, a form of emergence in which patterns at large scales are not traceable from lower scales. Our framework leverages various multivariate extensions of Shannon's mutual information, and introduces the O-information as a metric capable of representing synergy- and redundancy-dominated systems. We develop key analytical properties of the O-information, and study how it relates to other metrics of high-order interactions from the statistical mechanics and neuroscience literature. Finally, as a proof of concept, we use the proposed framework to explore the relevance of statistical synergy in Baroque music scores. (Abstract)
Saavedra, Serguei, et al. Common Organizing Mechanisms in Ecological and Socio-economic Networks. arXiv:1110.0376. With coauthors Felix Reed-Tsochas and Brian Uzzi, in a paper to appear in World Scientific’s Complex Systems and Interdisciplinary Sciences series, management theorists from Northwestern and Oxford University are able to discern implicate affinities between these disparate natural and human stages. Once again, as if a genetic program in effect, a constant anatomy and physiology accrues at each and every domain.
Previous work (Nature. 457/463, 2009) has shown that species interacting in an ecosystem and actors transacting in an economic context may have notable similarities in behavior. However, the specific mechanism that may underlie similarities in nature and human systems has not been analyzed. Building on stochastic food-web models, we propose a parsimonious bipartite-cooperation model that reproduces the key features of mutualistic networks - degree distribution, nestedness and modularity -- for both ecological networks and socio-economic networks. Our analysis uses two diverse networks: mutually-beneficial interactions between plants and their pollinators, and cooperative economic exchanges between designers and their contractors. We find that these mutualistic networks share a key hierarchical ordering of their members, along with an exponential constraint in the number and type of partners they can cooperate with. The surprising correspondence across mutualistic networks suggests their broadly representativeness and their potential role in the productive organization of exchange systems, both ecological and social. (Abstract)
Sakata, Shuzo and Tetsuo Yamamori. Topological Relationships between Brain and Social Networks. Neural Networks. 20/1, 2007. Cerebral information processing and friendship associations are found to develop and evolve in the same way, which suggests a unified phenomenal basis.
These results also imply the existence of underlying common principles behind the organization of brain and social networks. (12) This analogy between the role of explicit social attitudes in the establishment of social ties and that of molecular functions in the development of neuronal circuits raises an intriguing hypothesis that brain and social networks might contain similar connected structures. (12)
Sales-Pardo, Marta, et al. Extracting the Hierarchical Organization of Complex Systems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 104/15224, 2007. From Luis Amaral’s Complex Systems Institute at Northwestern University, a report on progress toward distilling a common, universal structure and dynamics of scale-free webs everywhere. The quote is from a caption.
Hierarchical structure of metabolic networks. (A) global-level affinity matrices and hierarchical trees for the USCD (Univ. Cal. San Diego) reconstruction of the metabolic network of E. coli. The overall organization of the network is similar and independent of the reconstruction used to build the network. (15229)
Salman, Hanna, et al. Universal Protein Fluctuations in Populations of Microorganisms. Physics Review Letters. 108/238105, 2012. Similar to Nacher and Ochiai above, University of Pittsburgh biophysicists detect a common explicate recurrence amongst life’s metabolisms of nature’s ubiquitous lineaments and vitality.
The copy number of any protein fluctuates among cells in a population; characterizing and understanding these fluctuations is a fundamental problem in biophysics. We show here that protein distributions measured under a broad range of biological realizations collapse to a single non-gaussian curve under scaling by the first two moments. Moreover, in all experiments the variance is found to depend quadratically on the mean, showing that a single degree of freedom determines the entire distribution. Our results imply that protein fluctuations do not reflect any specific molecular or cellular mechanism, and suggest that some buffering process masks these details and induces universality. (Abstract)
Sarpeshkar, Rahul. Analog Synthetic Biology. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society. Online March, 2014. Nature is not purely digital. While molecules are discrete and digital, all molecular interactions that lead to computation, e.g., association, transformation and dissociation chemical reactions, have a probabilistic analog nature to them. (2) A MIT bioelectrical engineer makes a strong claim that life does not evolve as isolate entities only, rather it is graced by equally real communicative interrelations. Thus a complementarity of analog and digital phase aspects would better distinguish organisms. It is also averred that Digital computation is a subset of analog computation, which we might note is akin to our own brains, especially a woman’s bicameral mind. Such insights and syntheses are then said to provide a better guide for palliative synthetic biology enhancements.
We analyse the pros and cons of analog versus digital computation in living cells. Our analysis is based on fundamental laws of noise in gene and protein expression, which set limits on the energy, time, space, molecular count and part-count resources needed to compute at a given level of precision. We conclude that analog computation is significantly more efficient in its use of resources than deterministic digital computation even at relatively high levels of precision in the cell. Based on this analysis, we conclude that synthetic biology must use analog, collective analog, probabilistic and hybrid analog–digital computational approaches; otherwise, even relatively simple synthetic computations in cells such as addition will exceed energy and molecular-count budgets.
Schack, Carolann, et al. Modularity is the Mother of Invention: A Review of Polymorphism in Bryozoans. Biological Reviews. Online November, 2018. Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand biologists post a 35 page study of how pervasive nature’s evolutionary and biological employ of semi-autonomous modular units within larger assemblies such as bodies and brains actually is. Some two decades after their initial view by Gunter Wagner and others, this efficient structural composition, famously noted by Herbert Simon (search) in the 1960s, can now be well affirmed across the Metazoan lineages.
Modularity is a fundamental concept in biology. Most taxa within the colonial invertebrate phylum Bryozoa have achieved division of labour through the development of specialized modules (polymorphs), and this group is well exemplifies this phenomenon. We provide a comprehensive description of the diversity, morphology and function of these polymorphs and the significance of modularity to the evolutionary success of the phylum, which has >21000 described fossil and living species. Modular diversity likely arose from heterogeneous microenvironmental conditions, and repeated module clusters are an emergent property of zooid plasticity. (Abstract excerpt)
Scheffer, Marten. Critical Transitions in Nature and Society. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009. Because research results are now sufficiently established and wide ranging, a Wageningen University (Netherlands) theoretical ecologist can accomplish a book length compilation of how life’s evolution, natural ecosystems, and human civilizations have each and all come to be poised in a dynamical self-organized state. An initial Part explains such Emergent Patterns in Complex Systems, which are then shown to universally apply, via Case Studies, from lakes, climate, the Cambrian burst of species, oceans to cities in unsustainable crisis. A running implication is that the whole biotic Earth ought to be seen as residing in a critical state between order and chaos, which now quite demands our mitigating analysis and attention. See also an article from a team lead by Scheffer "Early-Warning Signals for Critical Transitions," Nature (461/53, 2009).
Scheffer, Marten, et al. Early-Warning Signals for Critical Transitions. Nature. 461/53, 2009. A ten man team across the EU and USA find that when complex dynamical systems from climates and fisheries to asthma attacks and financial failures approach a “tipping point” bifurcation, certain constant signs become evident. These are: slower recovery from perturbations, increased autocorrelation (repeated patterns), and increased variance magnitude. Such phenomena are then seen to appear everywhere “…regardless of differences in the details of each system,” which would suggest an independent mathematical existence. See also Scheffer’s new book Critical Transitions in Nature and Society.
Schlosser, Gerhard and Gunter Wagner, eds. Modularity in Development and Evolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003. This comprehensive work on the constant employ of modular components and processes is reviewed more in Part V: A Quickening Evolution.
Modularity pervades every level of biological organization. From proteins to populations, larger biological units are built of smaller, quasi-autonomous parts. (Craig Nelson 17) The modular architecture of metazoan body plans is generated by a similarly modular genetic regulatory hierarchy. (CN 30)