V. Life's Corporeal Evolution Encodes and Organizes Itself: An EarthWinian Genesis Synthesis
3. Cellular Holobiont Symbiogenesis
Gontier, Nathalie. How Symbiosis, Horizontal Gene Transfer, and Virolution Call for an Extended Synthesis. http://aaas.confex.com/aaas/2013/webprogram/Session5780.html.. An AAAS session at the February 2013 Boston annual meeting, organized by the University of Lisbon philosopher. Speakers include Douglas Zook, “Symbiosis as a Driving Force of Evolution,” Frederic Bouchard “How Research on Symbiosis Should Transform Our Understanding of Adaption,” and Gontier on “Importance of Horizontal Evolution for the Sociocultural Sciences.” See also on this site a parallel session “How Macro-Evolutionary Studies Call for an Extended Synthesis.”
Comparative (meta)genomics have made us realize that horizontal evolutionary phenomena have been vastly underestimated. The serial endosymbiogenetic theory has proven the symbiogenetic origin of mitochondria and plastids. Symbiosis studies further prove that symbiotic unions continue to be relevant to understand evolution. Symbiotic unions can become transmitted vertically, from parent to offspring, through means other than germ-line transmission. Abundant evidence also exists for horizontal or lateral gene transfer in microorganisms. And evidence is piling up that lateral gene transfer also occurs abundantly in eukaryotic organisms. Gene sequencing techniques further prove that viruses also contribute to the evolution of life. They may have played a crucial role in the development of the genetic code, and viral genes are abundantly present in non-coding DNA regions that used to be designated as “junk DNA.” Such horizontal evolutionary phenomena pose major challenges to the Modern Synthesis, which makes a clear distinction between ontogeny and phylogeny, emphasizes germ-line transmission, and defines speciation as a splitting or “branching off” process. Horizontal evolutionary studies have consequences for how we define units of evolution, and biological individuals, how we draw the tree of life, and how we conceptualize speciation. (Session Abstract)
Gontier, Nathalie. Universal Symbiogenesis: An Alternative to Universal Selectionist Accounts of Evolution. Symbiosis. 44/1-3, 2007. A paper presented at the 5th International Symbiosis Society Congress in Vienna by the Vrije Universiteit Brussel research philosopher that begins with a good review of the Darwinian prevalence of selective winnowing alone. But as many writers aver, this view is an inadequate explanation that needs to be complemented and advanced by prior, innate affinities for mutual assembly. Examples are then offered across the strata from prokaryotes and viruses to cultures and languages to reveal how ubiquitous in nature this cooperative “hybridization” effect is. See also Nathalie's chapter Introducing Universal Symbiogenesis in Special Sciences and the Unity of Science, Olga Pombo, et al, eds. (Springer, 2012).
The process of symbiogenesis need not be confined to either the microcosm or the origin of eukaryotic beings. On the contrary, just as natural selection today is being universalized by evolutionary biologists and evolutionary epistemologists, symbiogenesis can be universalized as well. It will be argued that in its universalized form, symbiogenesis can provide: (1) a general tool to examine various forms of interaction between different biological organisms (regular symbiogenesis, hybridization, virus-host interactions), and (2) new metaphors for extra-biological fields such as cosmology, the cultural sciences, and language. Universal symbiogenesis can thus complement universal selectionist accounts of evolution. (167)
Gontier, Nathalie, ed. Reticulate Evolution. Berlin: Springer, 2015. “Reticulate” is meant to represent nature’s pervasive symbiogenesis by way of networks geometries. A lead chapter is Symbiosis – Evolution’s Co-Author by Douglas Zook, a colleague of the late Lynn Margulis. The University of Lisbon editor goes on to include horizontal gene transfer as another instance. A typical entry is Can We Understand Evolution Without Symbiogenesis? by Francisco Carrapico.
Gordon, Daniel, et al. Hierarchical Self-Organization of Cytoskeletal Active Networks. Physical Biology. 9/2, 2012. A “cytoskeleton” is the internal framework of a cell, composed of actin filaments and microtubules. Ben Gurion University of the Negev researchers testify to the exemplary presence of self-arranging dynamics as they scale into micro and macro cellular realms.
The structural reorganization of the actin cytoskeleton is facilitated through the action of motor proteins that crosslink the actin filaments and transport them relative to each other. Here, we present a combined experimental-computational study that probes the dynamic evolution of mixtures of actin filaments and clusters of myosin motors. While on small spatial and temporal scales the system behaves in a very noisy manner, on larger scales it evolves into several well distinct patterns such as bundles, asters and networks. These patterns are characterized by junctions with high connectivity, whose formation is possible due to the organization of the motors in 'oligoclusters' (intermediate-size aggregates). The simulations reveal that the self-organization process proceeds through a series of hierarchical steps, starting from local microscopic moves and ranging up to the macroscopic large scales where the steady-state structures are formed. (Abstract)
Guerrero, Ricardo and Mercedes Berlanga. From the Cell to the Ecosystem: The Physiological Evolution of Symbiosis. Evolutionary Biology. Online November, 2015. In this 2015 “Synthesis Paper,” University of Barcelona biologists trace nature’s pervasive mutualities across this wide expanse. Life’s origin is seen as a “biopoiesis,” from the Greek word for poetry, which then proceeds by virtue of autopoietic, holobiont “obligate coevolved partnerships” and “interdependent cooperative functional-metabolic interactions.” These effective propensities recur everywhere as microbial mats exemplify.
Hanczyc, Martin, et al. Experimental Models of Primitive Cellular Compartments. Science. 302/618, 2003. Whereof a persistent, natural tendency to form encapsulated, bounded protocells is identified, but, excuse me, life is not a ‘machine.’
The bilayer membranes that surround all present-day cells and act as boundaries are thought to have originated in the spontaneous self-assembly of amphiphilic molecules into membrane vesicles. (618) These experiments constitute a proof-of-principle demonstration that vesicle growth and division can result from simple physico-chemical forces, without any complex biochemical machinery. (621)
Harold, Franklin. Molecules into Cells: Specifying Spatial Architecture. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews. 69/4, 2005. The University of Washington microbiologist joins a growing movement to liberate organic form and development from a dogmatic 20th century genetic fixation. Rather, an array of non-genetic forces from innate dynamics to environmental constraints provides an “epigenetic” guidance. A number of recent papers noted on the website, such as by Albert, Mameli, Newman, Muller, Keller, Van Speybroeck, Levin, and Ma’ayan, describe an oriented, iterative emergence of development and evolution.
This exercise provides fresh support for a holistic point of view that diverges significantly from the opinions held, at least conventionally, by many molecular scientists. Spatial organization is not written out in the genetic blueprint; it emerges epigenetically from the interplay of genetically specified molecules, by way of a hierarchy of self-organizing processes, constrained by heritable structures, membranes in particular. (545) The hierarchy of order envisages a nested succession of stages, beginning with the translation of genetic information into functional proteins….If (cellular) unity can be discerned, it revolves around the kinds of processes that progressively build up structures, organization, and global form. The word to conjure with nowadays is self-organization. (545)
Harold, Franklin. The Way of the Cell. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001. A biochemist’s tour of the origins, evolution, symbiotic assembly, and autopoietic functions of cellularity. These insights are based on a unique blend of theories of thermodynamics, self-organization, and natural selection. But Harold remains a “materialist” and holds that life is due to “peculiar” complex systems which channel energy and information.
Helikar, Tomas, et al. The Cell Collective: Toward an Open and Collaborative Approach to Systems Biology. BMC Systems Biology. 6/96, 2012. In a paper akin to Karr, et al below, a team of ten University of Nebraska mathematicians and physicians propose an open source “Cell Collective Knowledge Base, Bio-Logic Builder, and Large-Scale Dynamical Models.” By these qualities, it is expected to facilitate an electronic cross sharing, as if an instant worldwide cognitive research activity.
Background Despite decades of new discoveries in biomedical research, the overwhelming complexity of cells has been a significant barrier to a fundamental understanding of how cells work as a whole. As such, the holistic study of biochemical pathways requires computer modeling. Due to the complexity of cells, it is not feasible for one person or group to model the cell in its entirety. Conclusions The Cell Collective is a web-based platform that enables laboratory scientists from across the globe to collaboratively build large-scale models of various biological processes, and simulate/analyze them in real time. In this manuscript, we show examples of its application to a large-scale model of signal transduction.
Hird, Myra. The Origins of Sociable Life. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009. The Queen’s University, Ontario, National Scholar of micro and macro organisms, writes a postmodern manifesto for an expanded evolutionary synthesis by way of the recognition and inclusion of symbiotic assemblies. In regard then, these vast, robust microbial realms might be availed as archetypal exemplars and guidance for more viable, coherent, sensitive organic societies.
Howard, Martin and Karsten Kruse. Cellular Organization by Self-Organization. Journal of Cell Biology. 168/4, 2005. Since cells are composed of many dynamically interacting elements or components, they exemplify the self-organizing behavior of complex systems. Another example of this formative natural agency at work.
We use the oscillating Min proteins of Escherichia coli as a prototype system to illustrate the current state and potential of modeling protein dynamics in space and time. We demonstrate how a theoretical approach has led to striking new insights into the mechanisms of self-organization in bacterial cells and indicate how these ideas may be applicable to more complex structure formation in eukaryotic cells. (533)
Igamberdiev, Abir, et al, eds. Symbiogenesis and Progressive Evolution. Biosystems. April, 2021. is a special collection edited by AI, Richard Gordon, and George Mikhailovsky which into the 2020s seeks to report frontier insights and evidence that nature’s constant preference for a mutual convergent synthesis of diverse members is in primary procreative effect everywhere. We note in this issue From Empedocles to Symbiogenetics: Lynn Margulis's Revolutionary Influence on Evolutionary Biology by Dorion Sagan and Symbiogenesis as a Driving Force of Evolution: The Legacy of Boris Kozo-Polyansky by Vladimir Agafonov, et al, Serial Endosymbiosis Theory: From Biology to Astronomy and Back to the Origin of Life by Predrag Slijepcevic (search) and Archaeal Origins of Eckaryotic Cells by Frantisek Baluska and Sherrie Lyons.
Symbiogenesis played a crucial role in the origin of eukaryotic cells and onto life’s emergence. It led to a complexification of coding systems as a result of merging individual genomes of prokaryotic cells. This issue will explore the role of horizontal gene transfer and symbiogenesis onto complex multicellular organisms. The papers herein will seek to understand the role of symbiogenesis in the evolutionary process and suggest computational models to describe the emergence of complex biological systems. The issue is dedicated to the founders of the concept of symbiogenesis Boris Kozo-Polyansky (1890-1957) and Lynn Margulis (1938-2011), the former chief editor of BioSystems, who proved this concept and introduced it into the mainstream of evolutionary theory. (Issue Introduction excerpt)